Bayport-Blue Point Boys Basketball: A Historic Season and a Promising Future Under Coach Charlie Peck
The 2025 winter season will long be remembered by the Bayport-Blue Point High School community as a year of records, resilience, and remarkable individual and team performances. Under the leadership of Head Coach Charlie Peck, the Boys Varsity Basketball team achieved one of its most successful seasons in program history. Finishing with a strong 17-5 record, the Phantoms not only proved themselves as a dominant force in their league but also laid the groundwork for a bright and exciting future.
A Season of Milestones
Coach Peck's squad had high expectations heading into the season, and the team delivered with intensity, determination, and a relentless work ethic. With a 17-5 finish and a deep playoff run that ended in the semifinals against eventual county champions Mount Sinai, the Phantoms solidified their place among the top programs in Nassau and Suffolk County.
“This team had everything — leadership, chemistry, and talent,” Coach Peck shared. “We came up short in the semis, but it doesn't take away from what this group accomplished. It was a historic season for Bayport-Blue Point.”
Star Power: Craig, Love, and a Cast of Standouts
At the center of the Phantoms’ success was senior Dylan Craig, who delivered one of the most dynamic seasons in Bayport-Blue Point history. Named MVP of the league, All-County, and selected to the prestigious All-Long Island Team, Craig was a scoring machine, averaging an astounding 28.3 points per game, the highest in both Nassau and Suffolk counties. He also led the team in steals, assists, and capped off his high school career as Bayport’s all-time leading scorer with 1,251 points.
“Dylan had the most electric senior year I’ve ever coached,” said Coach Peck. “He was not just a scorer, but a complete player and true leader.”
Craig was far from alone in carrying the load. Cormac Love was another offensive juggernaut, averaging 20 points per game and earning All-Conference and All-Academic honors. He set a county record with 105 three-pointers in a single season, an all-time mark that speaks to his elite shooting ability and work ethic.
In the paint, Evan Waldbauer provided physicality and consistency, averaging 9 rebounds and 10.5 points per game, while Sean Deutscher, an All-League selection, served as the emotional and defensive anchor for the team. Coach Peck described Deutscher as the "heart and soul" of the squad — the best defender and a relentless rebounder.
Colin Most, also an All-League honoree, brought a well-rounded game, posting 9 points, 8 rebounds, and 3 blocks per game, making crucial plays on both ends of the floor throughout the season.
Defining Moments and Turning Points
While each game held its own significance, Bayport-Blue Point’s resilience was tested and proven during tough league matchups and close contests that came down to execution in pressure situations.
Coach Peck highlighted the playoff loss to Mount Sinai as a moment of both frustration and growth. “They were the team to beat, and we gave them a battle,” he said. “It was disappointing, but it also gave our younger guys a taste of the intensity it takes to win in March.”
Rising Talent and Development
As the season unfolded, younger players gained valuable experience and started to emerge as future cornerstones. Coach Peck is particularly enthusiastic about his returning group, which is set to feature one of the tallest and most physically imposing front lines he’s ever coached at Bayport.
Next year’s roster will include Brayden Waldbauer (6'7"), Colin Most (6'4"), and Declan Schug (6'3") — a trio that promises to give opponents headaches in the paint. Paired with standout junior guard Chris Gorwitz, who is expected to run the offense with poise and pace, and sharpshooter Aidan Apicella, the Phantoms’ lineup will be deep, athletic, and versatile.
“We’ve been very good for the last five years,” said Coach Peck. “And looking at next year’s group, I don’t see a drop-off coming. In fact, we might be more balanced and tougher inside than ever before.”
Leadership and the Legacy of the Senior Class
The senior class of 2025 not only delivered exceptional performances on the court but also left a lasting legacy on the program. Their leadership, accountability, and unity were foundational to the team’s success. Players like Craig, Love, Deutscher, and Waldbauer set an example through their work ethic and commitment, helping to raise the standard for future teams.
“This group really set the bar,” Coach Peck noted. “They showed our underclassmen what it takes to win — not just with talent but with preparation and passion.”
Areas of Focus for Offseason Improvement
Despite all the success, Coach Peck remains focused on growth and continued development. He identified several key areas the team will address this offseason:
Interior defense and rim protection will be a priority, especially with a taller roster.
Enhancing ball movement and spacing to capitalize on shooting threats like Apicella and Gorwitz.
Physical conditioning to maintain tempo and defensive pressure over full games.
Continued work on basketball IQ and situational awareness, especially in late-game scenarios.
“We want to fine-tune the details,” said Peck. “When you’re close to the top, it’s the little things that make the biggest difference.”
Staying Connected
For fans interested in tracking the Phantoms’ stats, highlights, and player performances, game information and season summaries are typically available through the school’s athletic department and local sports media outlets. While a specific stats link wasn't provided, many follow Bayport-Blue Point via platforms like MaxPreps or school sports social media accounts.
Conclusion: The Best May Be Yet to Come
Coach Charlie Peck and the Bayport-Blue Point Boys Varsity Basketball team concluded the 2025 season with a powerful mix of historic achievement and future promise. With a 17-5 record, record-breaking performances, and a talented core set to return, the Phantoms are poised to build on their legacy of success.
The story of this year’s team is not just about points scored or games won — it’s about a culture that values hard work, resilience, and teamwork. As Coach Peck looks ahead, he sees not just potential, but purpose.
“This program is built to last,” he said. “The guys who wore the jersey this year left their mark. Now it’s time for the next group to rise.”
And rise they will — with height, talent, and a hunger to make history again.
Share With